Email Us 01473 688 100

Case Law

A ‘conscious decision’ is needed for there to be a detriment in whistle-blowing cases

In this case the Employment Appeal Tribunal (‘EAT’) had to decide whether an employee had suffered a detriment and been unfairly dismissed because she was a whistle-blower.

Chemistree v Gahir EAT March | 2014

The facts

Ms G was employed by the respondent, Chemistree, as a Responsible Pharmacist for only 18 days before being dismissed on the grounds of ‘mutual unsuitability’. Prior to Ms G’s dismissal she had sent two emails to her employer raising 17 concerns about health and safety and highlighting failures by her employer to comply with a number of statutory and regulatory requirements linked to the storage and dispensing of controlled medicines.

At the employment tribunal Ms G was successful: the tribunal held that the employer resented the fact that Ms G had criticised its practices and procedures and this led to Ms G being automatically unfairly dismissed because the ‘principal’ reason for her dismissal was that she made a protected disclosure (i.e. she was a whistle-blower).

The employment tribunal held that Ms G had also suffered a detriment as a result of making her protected discloses. This was on the basis that the respondent had failed to address her concerns or deal with them adequately. The tribunal was satisfied this caused Ms G to suffer the stress of having to remain at work knowing her employer was acting in breach of a number of significant obligations.

The respondent appealed to the EAT.

The EAT decision

Dismissal was automatically unfair

The EAT concluded that the employment tribunal had wrongly considered the protected disclosures in a ‘rolled up manner’ rather than considering each one separately and in detail. The EAT was quite critical of the tribunal’s reasoning and written judgment. The EAT reluctantly upheld the employment tribunal’s decision that Ms G had been automatically unfairly dismissed. The EAT was happy that the tribunal was justified, based on the evidence, in concluding that the principal reason for the dismissal was the making of protected disclosures. The EAT stressed that the reason for a dismissal is essentially a finding of fact by the tribunal that cannot be reversed unless it is perverse. However, it overturned the decision that Ms G had suffered a detriment as a result of raising her protected disclosures.

No detriment short of dismissal

In relation to the claim of detriment the EAT said that it must be shown that an employer has made a ‘conscious decision’ to treat an employee to his or her detriment for the employee to succeed. This may include a deliberate failure to act. In the absence of actual evidence of a failure to act, the decision will be treated as having been taken when the period expires within which the employer might reasonably have been expected to act.

In this case the EAT said that the tribunal had wrongly concluded Ms G had suffered a detriment given the limited time that passed between the emails being sent and her dismissal. The EAT judged it was difficult to see what detriment Ms G might have suffered during this short period of time.

The EAT criticised the employment tribunal for failing to separately identify each alleged protected disclosure and the statutory or regulatory basis for each alleged failure to comply with a legal obligation or health and safety breach.

In practice

Remember, there is no qualifying period needed to bring a claim of detriment or automatic unfair dismissal for whistle-blowing. If an employee does raise concerns about health and safety or legal obligations the employer should investigate them as soon as possible and report back to the employee. The employer should also try to ensure that the employee is not victimised or treated differently to any other non whistle-blowing employee. That said, if there are grounds to dismiss an employee, unrelated to the protected disclosures, the employer can still dismiss. However, we recommend employers take advice from us before doing so.

Book a phone consultation

Apply for a FREE phone consultation with one of our experienced employment law solicitors to discuss your case, how we can help and how much it is likely to cost.

Selected evening and weekend appointments available.

Tell us about your case

Our online form is the easy way to tell us about your case and employment details.

Short of time? Our ‘save and resume’ features let you save your answers and complete the form later.

Reasons to Choose
Quantrills Solicitors

Trusted advice

Attention to attention

Speed of response

Pragmatic solutions

FREE Employer

Subscribe to our email based hrlegalnews to receive details of our Knowledge Bank & HR Updates updates and our forthcoming events.

Client Testimonials

View more

Becoming our client is a straightforward process. However, before choosing Quantrills as your employment law solicitors you’ll want to be completely sure we are the right people to help you achieve your objectives. Having looked at our web site, if you like our approach and would like to discuss how we can help you, getting started is easy.

Step 1

Get in Contact

Contact us and tell us a little about your problem and the help you are looking for.

Step 2

We’ll contact you

We’ll follow up with a free no obligation initial telephone call or email to discuss your case.

Step 3

Invitation to become our client

Provided we are happy we can help you, we’ll invite you to become our client.

Step 4

You instruct us

If you agree to our invitation, you simply have to confirm this is writing or by email and confirm your instructions.

Step 5

We’ll start to act for you

Congratulations! You are now a client of Quantrills and we’ll start work on your instructions.

At Quantrills we are flexible in how we work with you and how we progress your case...

In Person

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua.

Get Directions

By Telephone

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua.

01473 688 100

Or request a call back

By Online Form

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua.

View Forms

By Email

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua.

Email us